Apply Now
For over a century, the Boy Scouts of America (BSA) has been known for its commitment to building character and teaching valuable life skills to boys. However, over the years, the BSA has faced various legal challenges, including lawsuits from girls who want to join the organization. In this article, we will explore the history, timeline, decisions, challenges, and social and legal implications of lawsuits to allow girls into the Boy Scouts of America.
Background on Boy Scouts of America (BSA)
The Boy Scouts of America (BSA) was founded on February 8, 1910, with the mission to prepare young people to make ethical and moral choices over their lifetimes. The organization aimed to instill values such as duty to God and country, helping others, and keeping oneself physically strong and mentally awake. For decades, the BSA operated as a boys-only organization, offering programs like Cub Scouts for younger boys and Boy Scouts for older boys. These programs included activities such as camping, hiking, and earning merit badges.
Lawsuits and Legal Challenges – Cases Where Girls Sued To Join the Boy Scouts
Over the years, several legal challenges were brought against the BSA by girls who wanted to join the organization. These lawsuits argued that excluding girls from the Boy Scouts violated their rights to equal treatment. Some notable cases include:
Goldstein v. Boy Scouts of America (1991): In 1991, the parents of Margot Goldstein (nee Mankes) filed a sex discrimination lawsuit against the Boy Scouts of America when their daughter was kicked out of a summer overnight camp and prevented from attending an all-boys sleep-away.
Yeaw v. Boy Scouts of America (1997): A young girl named Katrina Yeaw sought to join her twin brother’s Boy Scout troop but was denied. Her family sued, arguing that the exclusion was discriminatory. The court ultimately ruled in favor of the BSA, stating that the organization had the right to set its membership policies.
Timeline of Decision to Allow Girls
The BSA’s decision to allow girls was a gradual process influenced by legal challenges, changing societal norms, and declining membership numbers. Here is a timeline of key events:
- 2017: The BSA announced that it would allow girls to join the Cub Scouts program starting in 2018.
- 2018: The first girls joined Cub Scouts, and the program was renamed “Scouts BSA” to reflect the inclusion of both boys and girls.
- 2019: The BSA opened its flagship program, previously known as Boy Scouts, to girls. The organization began accepting girls into troops and allowing them to earn the prestigious rank of Eagle Scout.
- 2020: The first class of female Eagle Scouts was celebrated, marking a historic milestone for the organization.
How the BSA Integrated Girls into Their Programs
The integration of girls into the BSA’s programs required significant changes to the organization’s structure and operations. Here are some key steps the BSA took to ensure a smooth transition:
Separate Troops: The BSA created separate troops for boys and girls. This allows each group to have its own leadership and activities while maintaining the same standards and requirements.
Leadership Training: The BSA provided additional training and resources to leaders and volunteers to ensure they were prepared to support and mentor girls in scouting activities.
Program Adjustments: The BSA updated its program materials, including handbooks and merit badge requirements, to be inclusive and relevant to both boys and girls.
Promoting Inclusivity: The organization launched campaigns to promote the inclusion of girls and highlight the benefits of co-ed scouting. These efforts aimed to create a welcoming environment for all participants.
Changes in Membership Numbers since Allowing Girls
The decision to allow girls into the BSA had a significant impact on membership numbers. While the organization initially faced criticism and backlash from some members, it also saw an increase in interest and participation from girls and their families. Key changes in membership numbers include:
Increase in Cub Scouts Enrollment: The inclusion of girls in Cub Scouts led to a noticeable increase in enrollment numbers, with many families appreciating the opportunity for their daughters to participate in scouting activities alongside their brothers.
Growth in Scouts BSA Troops: The creation of separate troops for girls resulted in the formation of numerous new Scouts BSA troops across the country. These troops provided girls with opportunities to engage in outdoor activities, community service, and leadership development.
Overall Membership Trends: While the BSA experienced an overall decline in membership in recent years due to various factors, the inclusion of girls has helped stabilize and, in some areas, reverse the trend. The organization continues to focus on recruiting and retaining members by offering a diverse and inclusive scouting experience.
Legal and Social Implications of the Decision to Allow Girls
The decision to allow girls into the Boy Scouts had several legal and social implications:
Legal Precedents: The inclusion of girls sets a legal precedent for other organizations with gender-specific membership policies. It highlighted the importance of equal access and non-discrimination in youth programs.
Social Impact: Allowing girls to join the BSA contributed to broader societal shifts toward gender equality and inclusivity. It provided girls with opportunities to develop skills and confidence in a supportive environment.
Response from the Girl Scouts: The decision sparked reactions from the Girl Scouts of the USA, which expressed concerns about the potential impact on their membership and programs. However, both organizations continue to serve their unique missions and offer valuable experiences to young people.
Turn to High Rise Financial for Your Risk-Free Boy Scout Lawsuit Loan
If you have an ongoing lawsuit related to the Boy Scouts and are facing financial instability, you can apply for a no-risk lawsuit loan. Get in touch with us at High Rise Financial today to apply for our pre-settlement funding. Our trusted experts will be happy to speak with you and guide you through the application process. We’re proud to serve claimants with ongoing Boy Scout lawsuits in eligible states across the U.S. Call our toll-free number at (866) 921-5270 today to apply.